A federal judge has dismissed a discrimination lawsuit by a pastor who claimed that San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria violated his First Amendment rights by vetoing his reappointment to the city’s police-community advisory board, allegedly as retaliation for the pastor’s religious beliefs and controversial anti-LGBTQ remarks he made as a member of the county’s human relations commission.
U.S. District Judge Thomas Whelan ruled that Gloria has the right to choose advisory board members who share common political outlooks and priorities, and thus could veto the reappointment of Pastor Dennis Hodges to the city’s Citizens Advisory Board on Police/Community Relations without discriminating against or violating Hodges’ free-speech rights.
“The (San Diego Municipal Code) and City Charter establish that commonality of political purpose is an appropriate requirement for Advisory Board members,” Whelan wrote in his order granting Gloria’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit. “The Court finds that as a matter of law, Hodges cannot maintain his First Amendment retaliation claims against Mayor Gloria.”
Whelan also ruled that Hodges cannot amend his lawsuit, which judges often allow at this stage in a civil case, meaning Hodges’ only recourse would be to appeal the ruling to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Neither Hodges nor his attorneys immediately responded Tuesday to requests for comment.
Hodges is the founding pastor of the Church of Yeshua Ha Mashiach in Lemon Grove and worked for nearly 30 years for the California Department of Corrections. When the city in 2017 resurrected the Citizens Advisory Board on Police/Community Relations, he was one of the first members appointed.
The events at the heart of Hodges’ lawsuit, filed in November, revolve around comments he made as part of a different advisory body, the Leon L. Williams San Diego County Human Relations Commission. The commission was revived in May 2020 with a mission “to promote positive human relations, respect, and the integrity of every individual regardless of gender, religion, culture, ethnicity, sexual orientation, age or citizenship status.”
Hodges joined the commission in 2021 and was at the center of a controversy that erupted in November of that year when the commission discussed and voted to sign a letter condemning transphobia and recommitted to work to end discrimination against transgender people. Hodges abstained from voting and, when asked about it, made disparaging comments.
He later recounted saying during the discussion that “transgenderism … is an abomination in the eyes of God,” asserting that phrasing came directly from the Bible.
Community members and some fellow commissioners pushed for Hodges’ removal from the commission, and the county Board of Supervisors changed its bylaws to allow for the removal of commissioners.
In June 2022, the commission held a vote on his potential removal that required 13 commissioners to approve. Of the 19 commissioners in attendance that night, 10 elected to remove Hodges, six voted against his removal and the other three abstained, so he retained his seat on the commission.
Related Articles
Crime and Public Safety |
Source:: The Mercury News – Entertainment
